Professionals Separate Diamond Fact from Fiction
24 September, 2025
24 September, 2025
The internet is host to huge amounts of information, but this information isn’t always necessarily correct. For instance, you’ve likely read a significant amount about diamonds and diamond rings on the web, especially if you’re searching for a ring option for a significant other — but how do you know if what you’ve read is accurate?
The answer lies in working with a quality diamond professional like the team at AAA Jewelers, where our professionals will be happy to either confirm or correct diamond-related information you’ve read on the internet. We offer a huge range of stunning GIA diamonds for several purposes, from engagement and wedding rings to fashion jewelry and more. Let’s run through a few of the most common things you may have read about diamonds on the web, plus a quick fact check on each of these statements from our professionals that will inform you of whether what you’ve read is factual or a myth.
Statement: All Diamonds With the Same Carat Weight Appear Identical
Verdict: False
While it’s true that diamonds that have similar or identical carat weights will generally be similar in size, it’s not always the case that all diamonds with the same carat weight will be identical in every other respect. Diamonds are cut specifically to maximize their brilliance, durability, and sparkle; because of this, different diamonds will have unique numbers of facets, angles, etc.
You can often tell how a diamond has been cut by whether or not the bottom half is dark — light-colored diamonds were cut with low angles and will remain bright, whereas darker ones likely had a higher angle and will reflect less light. In addition, deep shapes like cushions and princess cuts often carry much more brilliance than others, meaning they’ll appear smaller from the top even though they have the same carat weight.
Long story short: Carat weight is far from the only factor that contributes to a diamond’s appearance, and two diamonds that have the same carat weight can appear very different from each other.
Statement: Diamonds With Fluorescence Can Be Great Choices
Verdict: Fact
While fluorescent diamonds have received some negative pub in certain circles in recent years, largely due to concerns that they will emit a hazy, milky or oily look, these concerns don’t reflect the frequency with which this happens — which is incredibly low, around 0.2% of all fluorescent diamonds to be exact. In most cases, fluorescence will appear as a subtle blue hue.
In fact, many people even prefer the look of a fluorescent diamond, as it appears more brilliant than a standard one. It’s worth noting that fluorescence is most common in certain colors of diamonds, namely yellows and pinks. Because yellow diamonds are the most popular of all, this means that many fluorescents will be yellows — but this doesn’t mean you should completely discount fluorescents if you’re looking for a pink or blue diamond, as they can be fantastic choices.
And of course, the fact that fluorescent diamonds may be slightly more affordable than standard diamonds is a nice bonus too.
Statement: Engagement Ring and Wedding Band Bridal Set Must Match
Verdict: False
Simply put, there is no “right” or “wrong” way to go when it comes to choosing engagement rings and wedding bands; in most cases, couples prefer their own separate styles. It’s also not unusual for a couple to wear matching diamond band sets at their wedding, but not at the reception dinner or other events that evening — again, this idea is based mostly on tradition and what others will expect of you rather than any sort of rule.
In fact, many couples choose not to wear matching sets, as they come from different cultures or have separate styles that would simply be inappropriate for a set to match. In most cases, it’s okay — and preferred! — for the rings to contrast each other, as long as one is a diamond band and one is a diamond solitaire.
Statement: Setting a Diamond Ring in Platinum or Gold Will Protect It from Scratches
Verdict: False
Platinum and gold are both extremely durable metals, but they do nothing to protect a diamond ring from scratches. In fact, many rings that have been set in platinum or gold end up with scratch marks because the metal is harder than diamonds — which means that it can actually be more likely to scratch or damage other items.
If you’re looking for diamond protection, you should go with tungsten, titanium, cobalt chrome, ceramic, or another strong but flexible material instead. These metals are just as durable and aesthetically pleasing as platinum and gold, but are far more resistant to scratching.
Statement: Diamonds Without Imperfections Are Flawless
Verdict: False
While diamonds absolutely do have flaws — the only stones that are completely flawless are synthetic ones — this doesn’t mean that you need to stay away from them if they’re not perfect. In fact, most men and women prefer imperfect diamonds, since these stones are more affordable and unique. It’s also worth mentioning that many flaws can be hidden simply by setting the diamond in a particular way.
In most cases, an “imperfect” diamond with some visible marks will cost less than a perfect stone — yet it might have far more character due to those marks. If you want something truly unique, imperfect diamonds are usually your best bet.
Statement: Diamonds With Visible Inclusions Are Less Desirable
Verdict: Fact
On the flip side of the above are any diamonds that have visible inclusions. Inclusions are flaws in a diamond’s makeup, and they come from the inclusion of foreign materials such as clouds or fractures. In many cases these flaws will appear as tiny dark circles or spots on a diamond — which can make them easy to miss if you’re not looking closely.
While diamonds with visible inclusions may be okay for some people, it’s generally accepted that they’re less desirable than those without them. This is because these types of diamonds are more likely to shatter or break, and they usually lack the clarity that you’d want in an engagement ring stone.
For more on the separation of diamond fact from fiction, or to learn about any of our engagement jewelry, wedding jewelry or other diamond needs, speak to the staff at AAA Jewelers today.